Rightly said, this isn't the normal domain of a DF analyst, but what I believe is it is certain for any LE Forensic analyst. This is where the main difference between a Non-LE and LE analysis.
Non-LE Analysis is calculated in terms of No. of hours of manpower and machine power spent or required + Amount of Data Extracted + fulfillment of Client's Requirements.
So, what about those data that neither matches the client's requirement nor the client is aware of its existence, nor the analyst has the capability or means to evaluate, extract and connect those vital pieces of information to each another, is it ok to overlook that? Isn't it a wastage of time and resources to depend on someone who doesn't have the required means in the first instance?
Whereas, LE are in a better position when compared to Non-LE with the availablity of vast resources and the analysis is calculated in terms of amount of intelligence and evidence gathered + connecting this acquired information to the past present and future scenarios as quick as possible, irrespective of manpower and machine power spent or required. And more importantly the percentage of success that can be achieved using this extracted information. This is just one of the many scenarios where an LE analysis will be far more tangible compared to Non-LE. And it's highly unlikely that this type of cases will ever be given out for private job work even for imaging and authentication given its nature of confidentiality and secrecy.
LE or not, we follow the requestor's requirements; whether that's solely to produce every .jpg file, or to pull out every single text string on the disk. The requestor manages the case and the resources at their disposal - one of which is the digital forensic analyst. Feedback from the analyst to the requestor may alter the course of the investigation, but that's not the analyst's call.
I would ask Bin Laden if he had a Court order and then I would want to see it.
I wouldn't broadcast anywhere what I was engaged on at any time nor would I advertise how I intended to carry out the exam - get a court order and you can see my notes and strategy.
Whereas, LE are in a better position when compared to LE or not, we follow the requestor's requirements; whether that's solely to produce every .jpg file, or to pull out every single text string on the disk. The requestor manages the case and the resources at their disposal - one of which is the digital forensic analyst. Feedback from the analyst to the requestor may alter the course of the investigation, but that's not the analyst's call.
I'd have to agree with Jonathan. Given the "blank check" (for those in the public domain) of find something, I would present all the data. Procedures don't vary. And while you could make the point to try to triage some of the data, you still might wind up having to use some of this information in court. You never know who they might decide to prosecute, terminally twisted or otherwise.
I would suspect that there might be several "unnamed" 3 letter agencies peaking over all shoulders as data is obtained to process any actionable items. They certainly have the skillsets, its the language processing that would probably give the most issues.
With respect to the raid on Bin laden, check out this link on Popular Mechanics Magazine regarding US Special Forces and the Forensic Toolkit they use
With respect to the raid on Bin laden, check out this link on Popular Mechanics Magazine regarding US Special Forces and the Forensic Toolkit they use
http//www.popularmechanics.com/technology/military/news/the-special-operations-forensic-tool-kit-metal-tec-1400#fbIndex11
Imagine that, the link goes straight to 'page 11 of 12' which is ADF Triage! lol
I'm not afraid to jump out and say what others are thinking.
Jamie, ADF has 6 posts, they all tout that product. There are other companies who actually offer content and ideas without just selling their product. Can you please look into this.
With respect to the raid on Bin laden, check out this link on Popular Mechanics Magazine regarding US Special Forces and the Forensic Toolkit they use
http//www.popularmechanics.com/technology/military/news/the-special-operations-forensic-tool-kit-metal-tec-1400#fbIndex11 Imagine that, the link goes straight to 'page 11 of 12' which is ADF Triage! lol
Yeah, give it a rest J.J. You're not going to do yourself any favours with this approach.
Jamie
Jamie,
My apologies if I have offended anybody. It was not my intention. It is a good article that mentions 12 tools and I did want to share it.
JJ
Jamie,
It is a good article that mentions 12 tools and I did want to share it.
…and casually instead of pointing to the first page of the article
http//
I posted a direct link to the 11th page that talked about my product…. roll
BTW, and IMHO the whole article looks A LOT like some form of advertising.
I don't buy, with all due respect with Popular Mechanics, that
In fact, teams are now equipped with state-of-the-art kits designed to collect any scrap of material and information from such raids, and PM discovered what's in the tool kits special operations forces carry with them.
You can read the bolded part above, as "
we have (from the actual guys that produce/sell this stuff) that they gave their products to the "special operations forces…."
and the bolded red part as
"… carefully AVOID carrying with them since they already carry some 30 Kgs/each of weapons, actually useful on the field tools like infrared viewers, etc. and that they supposedly keep in their labs, which are NOT managed by 6' 5", 110 Kg marines trained to survive and kill in secret operations but by actual bespectacled, shy and mostly harmless technicians".
Heck, I don't think the GI's will make a forensic acquisition of a 1 Tb HD on the field, possibly under enemy fire and anyway in a situation where seconds matter, let alone analyze anything, they simply grab whatever thay can, destroy anything they cannot carry back with them and get the hell out of there as soon as they can….
jaclaz











