The information below was reproduced from Sean Morrissey's website. It clearly has a significant impact how mobile telephone and computer examiners conduct examination and the methods they adopt to extract and harvest data.
iPhone Forensic Issues & Ethics
2. Jailbreaking the iPhone OS X. However, this method is not forensic and hasn’t been accepted in a court of law in the United States. In fact, this method violates US Copyright Laws
§ 506 · Criminal Offenses
Criminal Infringement.— (1) In general.—Any person who willfully infringes a copyright shall be punished as provided under section 2319 of title 18
§ 2319. Criminal infringement of a copyright
Any person who violates section 506 (a) (relating to criminal offenses) of title 17 shall be punished as provided in subsections (b), ©, and (d) and such penalties shall be in addition to any other provisions of title 17 or any other law.
First offense 5 years, and every subsequent offense 10 years.
Scroll down to bottom of page
http//
From my own research, the UK has its own approach and legal remedies to deal with these matters. Some years back Nokia made a presentation to APIGS about IP and DRM over issues on infringement.
While I am agreed that jailbreaking may not be forensically sound, I am not sure that every method for jailbreaking violates US copyright laws (and neither is the Electronic Frontier Foundation). Assuming that you have a license for OS X how would installing SSH and other tools violate the copyright?
Apple asserts that breaking the DRM violates the copyright because the DRM exists to protect Apple's intellectual property. EFF asserts that DRM exists not to protect the copyright, but to make it impossible to install applications not purchased through Apple or an Apple licensee.
The whole sordid mess can be found, here
http//
In any event, the issue is far from settled, IMHO. Further, it should be noted that US copyright law exists to protect innovation, not to restrict competition or progress. Many copyright holders assume that the protection is absolute but it isn't. To rise to the point where violation results in damages, Apple would have to show that it was harmed, economically, by the violation (such as when DVD producers suffer financial losses as a result of bootleg copies).
Apple could have a hard time defending itself if it tried to claim that a forensic investigator, operating in a professional capacity, caused any economic harm to Apple, by installing non-Apple software in order to unlock the device. It might also have a hard time convincing the court that it is harmed by the development of non-Apple applications for the iPhone if those applications can be shown to increase demand for the product.
However, a properly authorized (court or otherwise) legal access to a system or data qualifies under general 'saving' provisions in most instances. I am not intimately familiar with US law but are there not saving provisions that allow LE (and their supporting techs) to over-ride this? Most statutes allow intrusions and other such 'invasions' as being in the public interest (such as search warrants). I know US law tends to be more geared to the rights of the individual but I can't see how a law would be drafted or interpreted that would allow a crime to be shielded by such things as copy-right.
How do you folks in the US deal with the DMCA if you have to 'break' an encryption scheme? I was under the impression that there was a lot of concern among legitimate security researchers at one time about this kind of issue.
The following from the DMCA would appear to apply to jailbreaking, as argued by the EFF…
`(f) REVERSE ENGINEERING- (1) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsection (a)(1)(A), a person who has lawfully obtained the right to use a copy of a computer program may circumvent a technological measure that effectively controls access to a particular portion of that program for the sole purpose of identifying and analyzing those elements of the program that are necessary to achieve interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs, and that have not previously been readily available to the person engaging in the circumvention, to the extent any such acts of identification and analysis do not constitute infringement under this title.
`(2) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsections (a)(2) and (b), a person may develop and employ technological means to circumvent a technological measure, or to circumvent protection afforded by a technological measure, in order to enable the identification and analysis under paragraph (1), or for the purpose of enabling interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs, if such means are necessary to achieve such interoperability, to the extent that doing so does not constitute infringement under this title.
`(3) The information acquired through the acts permitted under paragraph (1), and the means permitted under paragraph (2), may be made available to others if the person referred to in paragraph (1) or (2), as the case may be, provides such information or means solely for the purpose of enabling interoperability of an independently created computer program with other programs, and to the extent that doing so does not constitute infringement under this title or violate applicable law other than this section.
I will leave it to Sean to explain the facts of his investigation and the elements that substantiate the suggestion of damage.
The DRM issue is something I added, only in relation to Nokia and Sean didn't mention that. The relevance of my comments is to raise the point a big name handset manufacturers is aware as to infringement issues. It isn't difficult to work out if Apple join with Nokia and others (and they have the money to do so) it could affect a lot more products than the discussion regarding Iphone and unlocking agents.
I cannot see that just because someone wishes to work as a forensic investigator it releases them to do whatever s/he wants and that the title of the job provides immunity.
With respect to economic loss, if by hacking the system it generates publicity the product is unsound/unsafe/insecure and sales drop, economic loss can occur here. If third party vendors seeks to invalidate agreements with Apple because of this matter, that too may amount to economic loss.
Substituting unauthorised code over the code that the manufacturer intended to be there may introduce infringement and/or economic loss. Moreover, if the unauthorised code also contains code belonging to the manufacturer may also amount to infringement and economic loss due to non-payment fo royalties.
An obvious question here though is "did the author of the hack/ crack/agent seek permission and was the author granted permission by Apple at first instance?" There is an advantage here for the code author, a financial gain obtained from selling each and every copy. Did the author pay royalties to Apple for the code to be used with Apple's product?
I was reading up about 'actionable foreign infringement.' It might be contrary to the terms of sale and/or use (eg of Iphone) that expressly forbids modifying the product (eg Iphone) without consent. For a fee, the infringer sells on the modification code to a UK entity who themselves go on to generate many copies of the modification. The infringer and the UK entity might be sued under the Brussels Regulation.
The above is by no means complete and I am not giving legal advice to anyone.
Let me offer this disclaimer, namely, that what I am referring to is US law and case precedent, not the interpretation of the DMCA as it applies to other countries or treaties.
The specific US code which pertains, most closely, to the iPhone issue is hacking/bypassing the DRM to install non-Apple software on the phone. It should also be mentioned that the DMCA expressly states that it cannot be construed to alter rights and responsibilities under US copyright law.
It is implied in US copyright laws and related protections that the purpose of such protections is to encourage innovation, not stagnate development. That is why algorithms cannot, normally, be copyrighted, only the specific implementations.
Case law in the US (including cases with which I have been a party), for the most part, does not side with the plaintiff in situations where the plaintiff alleges infringement with no actual damages. It also is not sympathetic to the use of copyrights to stifle competition. And, in the area of digital devices, it has recognized that interoperability is a concern as propriety, non-interoperable solutions would stifle competition.
The DMCA provides for regular review based upon changes to the state of the art, to allow for exemptions.
The Electronic Frontier Foundation makes a compelling case that Apple's use of DRM to protect OS X on the iPhone is anti-competitive (although there has been no official exemption, to date).
Further, with respect to forensics, the argument is considerably weaker because
1. Apple provides no forensically sound way to image iPhones so its policies stand in the way of others who might do so.
2. Because of 1, Apple is not in a position to claim material losses if someone else breaks the DRM in order to implement a process for forensic imaging.
3. Licensed users of software are entitled to a certain amount of "reverse engineering" if the result is to advance the goal of interoperation of their licensed products with products produced by others.
In the limited concept of forensics, under US law, I disagree that Apple has a compelling case, though EFF's petition, which is supported by many Apple competitors, has yet to be heard and adjucated.
As for the issue of economic loss due to adverse publicity, if anything, the result is the opposite. Hacking iPhones to allow interoperability with other networks has increased iPhone popularity and competition in the marketplace has forced Apple to do this, themselves.
All of this will, at some point, be settled by the US government, but as the law is written, Apple's arguments seem weak, especially insofar as hacking for forensic purposes is concerned.
In other words, I think the claim that jailbreaking an iPhone is, de facto, illegal, is a stretch, at least in the US.
>>snip.
I cannot see that just because someone wishes to work as a forensic investigator it releases them to do whatever s/he wants and that the title of the job provides immunity.
>>snip
This is related to the point I was making. Just because you are a locksmith and can pretty much enter any house you wish doesn't mean you are authorized to do so on your whims. You have to have a demonstrable right and reason to do so or you are guilty of house-breaking. If you have a court or statutory right to circumvent some protection scheme in order to effect a legal examination then you should be 'saved' by the statute involved. The most obvious example that comes to mind is border searches of electronic media and devices. When you think of it, you are looking for evidence of Child Porn (usually) and that is pretty far removed from the original purpose of a Customs inspection, protecting the border from smuggling activity which is historically the protection of duty and tariff revenue. However, border agents can effect warrantless searches as they see fit in order to discharge their duty and use whatever reasonable means they require to conduct those searches. They are 'saved' by the statute that would otherwise require judicial oversight to undertake a search.
Well guys, I had an interesting discussion with a US IP Attorney tonight (UK time) and I will endeavour to post some of the replies. In fairness, he did point out that the quotation of US law reference was inaccurate and incomplete. He identified the following
"Unfortunately that is an incomplete and inaccurate section 506 on copyrights. Below is the complete text of section 506 and 507 for more context. Subsections (A)-(C) under 506(a)(1) show it is much more limited than appears from the quoted blog.
§ 506. Criminal offenses4
(a) Criminal Infringement. —
(1) In general. — Any person who willfully infringes a copyright shall be punished as provided under section 2319 of title 18, if the infringement was committed —
(A) for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain;
(B) by the reproduction or distribution, including by electronic means, during any 180-day period, of 1 or more copies or phonorecords of 1 or more copyrighted works, which have a total retail value of more than $1,000; or
(C) by the distribution of a work being prepared for commercial distribution, by making it available on a computer network accessible to members of the public, if such person knew or should have known that the work was intended for commercial distribution.
(2) Evidence. — For purposes of this subsection, evidence of reproduction or distribution of a copyrighted work, by itself, shall not be sufficient to establish willful infringement of a copyright.
(3) Definition. — In this subsection, the term “work being prepared for commercial distribution” means —
(A) a computer program, a musical work, a motion picture or other audiovisual work, or a sound recording, if, at the time of unauthorized distribution —
(i) the copyright owner has a reasonable expectation of commercial distribution; and
(ii) the copies or phonorecords of the work have not been commercially distributed; or
(B) a motion picture, if, at the time of unauthorized distribution, the motion picture —
(i) has been made available for viewing in a motion picture exhibition facility; and
(ii) has not been made available in copies for sale to the general public in the United States in a format intended to permit viewing outside a motion picture exhibition facility.
(b) Forfeiture and Destruction. — When any person is convicted of any violation of subsection (a), the court in its judgment of conviction shall, in addition to the penalty therein prescribed, order the forfeiture and destruction or other disposition of all infringing copies or phonorecords and all implements, devices, or equipment used in the manufacture of such infringing copies or phonorecords.
© Fraudulent Copyright Notice. — Any person who, with fraudulent intent, places on any article a notice of copyright or words of the same purport that such person knows to be false, or who, with fraudulent intent, publicly distributes or imports for public distribution any article bearing such notice or words that such person knows to be false, shall be fined not more than $2,500.
(d) Fraudulent Removal of Copyright Notice. — Any person who, with fraudulent intent, removes or alters any notice of copyright appearing on a copy of a copyrighted work shall be fined not more than $2,500.
(e) False Representation. — Any person who knowingly makes a false representation of a material fact in the application for copyright registration provided for by section 409, or in any written statement filed in connection with the application, shall be fined not more than $2,500.
(f) Rights of Attribution and Integrity. — Nothing in this section applies to infringement of the rights conferred by section 106A(a).
§ 507. Limitations on actions5
(a) Criminal Proceedings. — Except as expressly provided otherwise in this title, no criminal proceeding shall be maintained under the provisions of this title unless it is commenced within 5 years after the cause of action arose.
(b) Civil Actions. — No civil action shall be maintained under the provisions of this title unless it is commenced within three years after the claim accrued."
Sorry, I miss the point. Apple is not alleging copyright violations, per se, but violation of the DMCA. In fact, installing additional software on the iPhone would not be a copyright violation (although it may violate other provisions of the contract, which would be civil, not criminal, acts). Apple provides a means to backup and restore iPhone images, thus, following the procedure recommended by Jonathan Zdziarski would not, under most circumstances, violate the copyright laws.
In other words, US copyright law is not the issue, period.
Your IP attorney is quoting copyright law. What I posted was the DMCA.
Now, the DMCA prohibits breaking of digital rights management code when such is used to protect copyright. But that isn't the case with jailbreaking!
seanmcl, you are quite right your post does discuss DMCA. But the origination of this thread came about because of observations raised by Sean at OSXForensics website with respect to copyright. His point didn't actually inject whether Apple had taken or were to take action, but mentioned copyright infringe in terms of jailbreaking and what that might mean. The replies I gave were in relation to that so as to avoid capsizing this thread with the DMCA issue clashing and outweighing the copyright issue. Some readers may find it confusing to start with a copyright matter and actually end up discussing a separate integer in the law. The US IP Attorney responded quite correctly to the points in the discussion at OSXForensics website.
I did say in my second reply that the DRM were my comments and not Sean's (from OSXForensics), and specifically why I referred to APIGS - the UK parliamentary committee that looked at issues of criminalisation for certain types of IP infringement.












