Take the State of DFIR Survey Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report.

Take the survey

Take the State of DFIR Survey

Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report.

Take the survey →
Notifications
Clear all

Oxygen / MobilEdit

3 Posts
3 Users
0 Reactions
1,890 Views
(@armresl)
Noble Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 1011
Topic starter   [#7998]

For those with experience with one or both. What are the pros/cons of each.

Assuming forensic suite version of each.

Thanks.



   
Quote
(@ursdestiny)
Eminent Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 47
 

Well the major difference I found is mobiledit is more friendly in use. But the Nokia PM viewer of oxygen is a thumbs up if you get S30/S40 Nokia mobiles. They support almost the same sets.



   
ReplyQuote
(@garyp)
New Member
Joined: 16 years ago
Posts: 3
 

I own MobileEdit Forensics and Oxygen Forensics 2011 Pro. I'm still new at both and learning, so I'm not an expert at either.

The few times I've used them, I noticed that ME did real well with the older phones and SIM card reading. For todays smartphones, I've had better results with Oxygen. On an iPhone I did recently, Osygen grabbed much more information than ME. Although, on ME's website they mention the limitations on iPhone reading at the moment, so it wasn't a surprise. They're working on it, and I'm sure they'll get more features in that area.

On an Android, I found them to be similar, although I really like how Oxygen grabbed the location information and tied it in with Google maps. Makes for a nice report.

Oxygen seems more feature rich, and I love the built-in SQL Lite reader.

I'm keeping both in my toolkit though. I like both of them; and as I've learned from the more experienced people here, more than one tool is often necessary.

Hope that helps.

Gary



   
ReplyQuote

Enterprise Partners

  • MagnetForensics_ForensicFocus
  • semantics21 2026 FF logo
  • atola-logo
  • celebrite-logo

Partners

  • Aid4Mail-Logo
  • gmdsoft-logo
  • ADF
  • Logo_MSAB_Black (2)
  • logo Belkasoft 135x100
  • detego-logo

Academic Partners

  • University of Southampton logo 2
Share: