Take the State of DFIR Survey Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report. Take the survey ›

Take the survey

Take the State of DFIR Survey

Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report.

Take the survey →
Notifications
Clear all

VM fot court

20 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
2,410 Views
(@nicci)
Active Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 15
Topic starter   [#4935]

Hello.

I have to go in court room in two weeks, but I have a problem.

The judge wants to start the computer that is seized as evidence and I can not allow that to happen – the last access dates are really important. I have the EnCase image of the drive which is 8GB SSD. I am thinking to make a VM that will contain the image, so I’ll be able to show the machine working in the court room without starting the real netbook. I think that it’s not necessary to include the whole image, because all I can use for the presentation is 8GB USB pen drive, which is 50 MB smaller that the raw image acquired by EnCase, and I also have to fit there the VM settings and VM installation. In the court room there will be no need to have all unallocated space, because I won’t perform the examination there. The lawyer wants to see how the windows is started, what apps starts with the OS and is Skype client attempting to logon when the user in question is logged in Windows.

So here are the questions
1. In my report I state that the start of the computer will effectively destroy metadata such as last accessed and last written. Is it a good idea to make such VM that will only contain the nonerased data?
2. If it’s not a good idea will the archiving the VM be a good idea?
3. Will I be able make a VM using VM Ware, that will work like the seized machine?

Thanks in advance

Nicci



   
Quote
binarybod
(@binarybod)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 272
 

Nicci

Check out VFC. There are lots of other options but this is the one I use on a regular basis.

Paul



   
ReplyQuote
(@brede)
Trusted Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 64
 

If we talking about tools check a free LiveView tool
http//liveview.sourceforge.net/



   
ReplyQuote
keydet89
(@keydet89)
Famed Member
Joined: 22 years ago
Posts: 3568
 

1. In my report I state that the start of the computer will effectively destroy metadata such as last accessed and last written. Is it a good idea to make such VM that will only contain the nonerased data?

Copy the image, verify the MD5, and use the copy…that way you won't even touch the original.



   
ReplyQuote
(@fuzed)
Trusted Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 93
 

yep agree with keydet - create a exact copy of the drive and use that, will do the same job.



   
ReplyQuote
(@ctendell)
Trusted Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 62
 

yep agree with keydet - create a exact copy of the drive and use that, will do the same job.

And I'll add one more to the fire. I agree with Keydet89. Make a copy and use VFC or live view. Be prepared to explain that this is exactly how the machine would have booted had they booted if from the machine itself.

With the exception of the hardware difference. Which may go to far into the technical.



   
ReplyQuote
Beetle
(@beetle)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 318
 

Liveview is 'the bomb' for this kind of issue.



   
ReplyQuote
(@douglasbrush)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 812
 

Wait I was under the impression Harlan was suggesting using the copy in the machine live and avoid the VM. It sounds as if it would be easier in a court environment to use the actual box with a verified copy and chain of custody documentation on the original in preservation. This way you give the court what they want and maintain forensic integrity of the original with less hoop jumping.



   
ReplyQuote
(@kovar)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 805
 

Greetings,

To elaborate a bit on what Doug said, clone the original media either with a hardware device or by blowing your image onto a new device, document why the new image is the same as the original, install the new device in the subject's hardware and take that into court.

I'd do this a few times in your lab, including booting the system, then do it one final time for court without turning the machine on so you can reasonably state that they're seeing the system in the same state that it was in when you imaged it.

-David



   
ReplyQuote
Brett Shavers
(@bshavers)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 215
 

The VM method will be the easiest and most time effective method. If you boot the original or a copy of the original, you will change data (of course). If, for any number of reasons, it is ordered to boot again, poke around the computer, etc on multiple occasions, each subsequent action will be affecting the computer, so you won't be looking at the original state each time. You will be booting a 'new' original drive as each time the data will be different, at least in the totality of data, there will be differences between the original evidence hard drive and each subsequent reboot of it.

With a VM, you can revert back to the original snapshot, so no matter how many times it is ordered to boot, you can boot the 'original' each time. You can even take snapshots during the demonstrations if needed.

Also, it is much easier to create a record of the viewing of the process and booting of the evidence drive with a VM by way of a screen capture/video, should a jury or judge wish to review the booting of the drive before rendering a ruling. I've made notations on videos for review with Camtasia to help reviewers understand what they were watching. I've created one video, copied the video and on the copy, placed my notes on the video (arrows with descriptions of what was happening). That gives the trier of fact or client, the ability to see both a clean operation as well as see the operation with descriptive sub-titles.

However, after discussing the pro's and con's of booting the original, if the judge says, "I want that original computer booted", then the answer is, "Yessir".



   
ReplyQuote
Page 1 / 2
Share: