Take the State of DFIR Survey Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report. Take the survey ›

Take the survey

Take the State of DFIR Survey

Caseloads, AI, tools and careers. 8 minutes, anonymous, early access to the report.

Take the survey →
Notifications
Clear all

VM fot court

20 Posts
13 Users
0 Reactions
2,411 Views
Beetle
(@beetle)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 318
 

Greetings,

To elaborate a bit on what Doug said, clone the original media either with a hardware device or by blowing your image onto a new device, document why the new image is the same as the original, install the new device in the subject's hardware and take that into court.

I'd do this a few times in your lab, including booting the system, then do it one final time for court without turning the machine on so you can reasonably state that they're seeing the system in the same state that it was in when you imaged it.

-David

Have you had challenges requiring explanations of the differences between the running system as encountered and the 'demo' setup when the hardware and drivers were not be the same? Just curious because we typically do not detain the box(s) so we can never be sure that a 'restored' set-up is going to be "absolutley identical" to the original system we encountered on site.



   
ReplyQuote
(@kovar)
Prominent Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 805
 

Have you had challenges requiring explanations of the differences between the running system as encountered and the 'demo' setup when the hardware and drivers were not be the same? Just curious because we typically do not detain the box(s) so we can never be sure that a 'restored' set-up is going to be "absolutley identical" to the original system we encountered on site.

Greetings,

I've not had this situation go to court so I'm not the best person to answer your question. My feeling is that documentation, using processes and tools that are commonly used by other examiners, and working from an understanding that the environment *isn't* exactly identical will carry the day if presented by a good lawyer and examiner.

Will changing from a physical SCSI disk to a virtual IDE disk, with the associated driver changes in the OS, change the fact that IE, LimeWire, and MSN chat start automatically when the user logs in? I think you should be able to argue that the change from physical to virtual had no impact on this behavior.

-David



   
ReplyQuote
Beetle
(@beetle)
Reputable Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 318
 

>>snip

Will changing from a physical SCSI disk to a virtual IDE disk, with the associated driver changes in the OS, change the fact that IE, LimeWire, and MSN chat start automatically when the user logs in? I think you should be able to argue that the change from physical to virtual had no impact on this behavior.

-David

My experience with some defence lawyers has been the "Is the court seeing an exact copy of the data?" kind of question arises quite often on cross. It is easy to answer when you are referring to discrete files which were extracted for analysis/tendering and their matching hashes on the source media, but I am somewhat concerned whether any traction can be gained with 'the media doesn't match anymore' ploy when you have recreated the system with a 'cloned' drive and a different hardware environment.

I don't disagree with you, I am just wondering what the experience in the States has been.



   
ReplyQuote
Brett Shavers
(@bshavers)
Estimable Member
Joined: 21 years ago
Posts: 215
 

With photos, including digital photos of a crime scene/pictures of evidence, the witness is usually asked if the photos are an accurate representation of the items or scene in question. I've not ever been asked if a photo that I had taken, was an exact representation of the objects in the photo. I'd say that booting a VM or a clone, with different hardware or not, would be fair to say its an accurate representation of the original system.



   
ReplyQuote
(@nicci)
Active Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 15
Topic starter  

Thanks for the interest in the discussion.

My problem is that the netbook is Acer Aspire One ZG5 – which means SSD with really weird interface and no place in the case to even try some connectors. Also I can not buy any different memory than 8 GB pen drive I received from court, so I can not copy the windows to that 8 GB drive and boot from it (I have tryied for days but it didn’t boot). I tried the solution with mounting the immage, and making VM with that) so I’ll have to work with that in mind (besides everithing that I do will have to be verified from another expert in necessary). The computer won’t be booted, because the dates and the unallocated space is really important for the outcome of the trial and if needed some other expert must be able to have the same results, which will be impossible if the netbook is started without write protection.

Thanks for the feedback, and I’ll have the sugestions in mind.

Cheers
Nicci



   
ReplyQuote
(@douglasbrush)
Prominent Member
Joined: 18 years ago
Posts: 812
 

It is a very interesting scenario and one we will see more of as new devices such as netbooks become more popular and end up on our respective plates. Nicci do keep the forum abreast of development and how things work out.



   
ReplyQuote
jaclaz
(@jaclaz)
Illustrious Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 5133
 

Thanks for the interest in the discussion.
so I can not copy the windows to that 8 GB drive and boot from it (I have tryied for days but it didn’t boot).

No, the Windows can be "ported" to work on USB but it is NOT easy., and however it will "alter" the image (drivers, Registry settings, etc, but this would happen also in the VM).

Also I can not buy any different memory than 8 GB pen drive I received from court….

It seems you have no way out (due to size) than to re-size the image "losing" unused sectors.
Since you are in this particular case requested to show only the "normal" behaviour of the computer, it should not create a problem. ?

Or cannot you (say) gzip the dd image and put it on the 8GB key, then copy it expanding in it on a Temp directory of the machine and start the VM with the expanded copy?

jaclaz



   
ReplyQuote
(@jgoss)
Trusted Member
Joined: 19 years ago
Posts: 59
 

I'd recommend VFC. We use it a lot at work, although no-ones been brave enough to take it to court yet (But then we hardly ever go to court)



   
ReplyQuote
(@nicci)
Active Member
Joined: 17 years ago
Posts: 15
Topic starter  

I'm making the VM and rehearsing, what I’m going to do in court.

The hearing starts on 07-th and ends on 09-th of December, and I do not know when exactly I will present my findings, so I’ll write what happened and was it accepted by the court.

Cheers

Nicci



   
ReplyQuote
(@mickpen)
Active Member
Joined: 20 years ago
Posts: 9
 

Nicci

Good luck with your case, I for one would be very interested in the outcome, I am aware that the product from VFC has been used extensively in interviews and via statement / reports submitted but yours is the first live showing of a VM of a suspect machine in a court environment that I am aware of.

If there is anything I can do to assist, particularly with the impact of system changes on user data, please feel free to contact me.

Michael Penhallurick



   
ReplyQuote
Page 2 / 2
Share: