UK Government Seeks Expert Views On Computer Evidence
Can we still trust computer-generated evidence? The UK government launches a call for evidence to review its role in criminal cases—share your insights before 15 April 2025!
Share
About this article
News 28 January 2025 2 min read 513 words

by Si Biles, co-host of the Forensic Focus Podcast
The British Government has opened a “call for evidence” in a re-evaluation of the presumption of accuracy of computer-generated records. The call, titled “Use of evidence generated by software in criminal proceedings: Call for Evidence”[1], was published on the 21st January, 2025 and is seeking responses by 11:59pm on the 15th April, 2025.
The matter has come to the fore after the significant publicity regarding what is known in the UK as “The Post Office Scandal”,[2] where a system called ‘Horizon’, produced by Fujitsu,[3] was central to the controversy. The failures in the system appear to have been responsible for in excess of 700 prosecutions for crimes such as theft and false accounting. Hundreds of people were sent to prison, were assigned community service, had to wear monitoring bracelets and were given criminal records. Yet it seems that the discrepancies within the accounting systems were down to computer error and not human actions. The presumption of the “computer being right” was a contributing factor in these prosecutions.[4]
This presumption wasn’t always the status quo. Historically in the UK, the 1984 Police and Criminal Evidence Act put the onus on the prosecution to show:
… that at all material times the computer was operating properly …
However, this was replaced in a complete about face in 2000 with the presumption that the computer was operating correctly unless it could be shown (by the Defence) that it wasn’t operating correctly.
It’s now a quarter of a century since the last review of the presumptions that should be made regarding computer-generated material, and the technological landscape has changed beyond recognition. The prevalence and proliferation of computer-based evidence in a majority of criminal cases, along with the advent of machine learning software where the internal workings are unknown, makes a continued presumption of correctness a dangerous threat to a fair and functional justice system.
If you are based in the UK, then you are able to contribute to the call directly. Alternatively, if you are unable to complete the full survey or have concerns about sharing your input openly, then Dr Angus Marshal[5] of the University of York and the Digital Evidence Virtual Centre of Excellent (DEVCE)[6] is anonymously collating responses for submission. You can fill out that form here.
It is crucial that as many viewpoints as possible, particularly those of practitioners at the forefront of digital forensics in the UK, are submitted. This will help establish a consensus to guide us forward, especially as, at this rate, it may well not be reviewed again until 2050!
[1] https://www.gov.uk/government/calls-for-evidence/use-of-evidence-generated-by-software-in-criminal-proceedings/use-of-evidence-generated-by-software-in-criminal-proceedings-call-for-evidence
[2] https://www.computerweekly.com/feature/Post-Office-Horizon-scandal-explained-everything-you-need-to-know
[3] Originally created by ICL, which was acquired by Fujitsu in 1998
[4] It should be noted that there is also a raft of non-technical problems in the scandal to do with some appallingly unethical behaviour by those involved in the prosecution of alleged crimes.
[5] https://www.linkedin.com/in/angusmarshall/
[6] https://www.linkedin.com/company/digital-evidence-virtual-centre-of-excellence-cic/






